[Openmcl-devel] cl-bench Windows 32-bit performance

Brandon Van Every bvanevery at gmail.com
Thu Apr 14 01:25:15 UTC 2011


http://trac.clozure.com/ccl/wiki/HowFastAreWe presents some results
using cl-bench.  How to obtain and use cl-bench is documented at
http://www.cliki.net/Performance_Benchmarks .  I added a section on
how to run the benchmarks using a Windows .bat file.  Here are my
initial results.  I'm running Windows Vista on a Dell Inspiron 1720
laptop with a 2GHz Intel Core 2 Duo processor and 2GB RAM.  I left
system tray items, Firefox, and a few text files running in the
background, but I did not bring any of those things to the foreground
while running the tests.  This is a machine with a "typical background
load" on it; it has not been specially configured to maximize
benchmarking results.

The raw hardware specs of my machine are roughly comparable to
"MacBook Pro, Intel Core 2 Duo @2.33 GHz" machine on the Cliki page.
The reference implementation for that benchmark is "SBCL 1.0.2 (binary
download)".  Roughly eyeballing it, I find my "Clozure Common Lisp
Version 1.7-dev-r14645M-trunk  (WindowsX8632)" benchmark is 2x..5x
slower in many cases.  It's also slower than the "OpenMCL Version
1.1-pre-061231 (DarwinX8664)" maybe by 1.5x..4x depending.  The
comparison math is difficult as I have to mentally renormalize the
numbers; I will try to work up a comparison to SBCL.  SBCL's support
of Windows is in a seemingly endless Alpha, so I'm not sure if I can
actually bench it, but I'll try.

I am wondering whether the 32-bit version is significantly slower than
the 64-bit version.  Hmm, another possibility is I am using the "dev"
version.


Cheers,
Brandon Van Every


;; -*- lisp -*-  Clozure Common Lisp Version 1.7-dev-r14645M-trunk
(WindowsX8632)
;;
;; Implementation *features*:
;; (:PRIMARY-CLASSES :COMMON-LISP :OPENMCL :CCL :CCL-1.2 :CCL-1.3
:CCL-1.4 :CCL-1.5 :CCL-1.6 :CLOZURE :CLOZURE-COMMON-LISP :ANSI-CL
:OPENMCL-UNICODE-STRINGS :OPENMCL-NATIVE-THREADS :OPENMCL-PARTIAL-MOP
:MCL-COMMON-MOP-SUBSET :OPENMCL-MOP-2 :OPENMCL-PRIVATE-HASH-TABLES
:X8632-TARGET :X8632-HOST :X86 :X86-TARGET :X86-HOST :WINDOWS-HOST
:WINDOWS-TARGET :WIN32-TARGET :WIN32-HOST :32-BIT-TARGET :32-BIT-HOST
:WINDOWS :LITTLE-ENDIAN-TARGET :LITTLE-ENDIAN-HOST)
;;
;; Function                      real     user     sys       consed
;; ----------------------------------------------------------------
;; COMPILER                      3.05     2.98     0.00            0
;; LOAD-FASL                     0.34     0.28     0.00            0
;; SUM-PERMUTATIONS              5.71     5.43     0.00            0
;; WALK-LIST/SEQ                 0.06     0.06     0.00            0
;; WALK-LIST/MESS                0.07     0.05     0.00            0
;; BOYER                        13.31    13.09     0.00            0
;; BROWSE                        0.81     0.73     0.00            0
;; DDERIV                        0.90     0.95     0.00            0
;; DERIV                         0.97     0.90     0.00            0
;; DESTRUCTIVE                   0.67     0.64     0.00            0
;; DIV2-TEST-1                   1.39     1.23     0.00            0
;; DIV2-TEST-2                   1.58     1.48     0.00            0
;; FFT                           0.29     0.23     0.00            0
;; FRPOLY/FIXNUM                 1.03     1.03     0.00            0
;; FRPOLY/BIGNUM                 1.21     1.19     0.00            0
;; FRPOLY/FLOAT                  1.98     1.86     0.00            0
;; PUZZLE                        1.92     1.81     0.00            0
;; TAK                           0.82     0.87     0.00            0
;; CTAK                          1.35     1.50     0.00            0
;; TRTAK                         0.83     0.83     0.00            0
;; TAKL                          1.57     1.58     0.00            0
;; STAK                          1.60     1.73     0.00            0
;; FPRINT/UGLY                  10.48    10.62     0.00            0
;; FPRINT/PRETTY                 7.12     7.43     0.00            0
;; TRAVERSE                      1.92     1.75     0.00            0
;; TRIANGLE                      2.05     2.01     0.00            0
;; RICHARDS                      4.51     4.46     0.00            0
;; FACTORIAL                     1.44     1.42     0.00            0
;; FIB                           0.31     0.31     0.00            0
;; FIB-RATIO                     0.14     0.14     0.00            0
;; ACKERMANN                     2.62     2.73     0.00            0
;; MANDELBROT/COMPLEX            0.72     0.69     0.00            0
;; MANDELBROT/DFLOAT             0.35     0.39     0.00            0
;; MRG32K3A                     14.75    14.71     0.00            0
;; CRC40                        44.38    44.15     0.00            0
;; BIGNUM/ELEM-100-1000          2.26     2.31     0.00            0
;; BIGNUM/ELEM-1000-100         16.50    16.16     0.00            0
;; BIGNUM/ELEM-10000-1          18.34    17.83     0.00            0
;; BIGNUM/PARI-100-10            8.12     8.10     0.00            0
;; BIGNUM/PARI-200-5           126.43   125.46     0.00            0
;; PI-DECIMAL/SMALL            106.09   106.36     0.00            0
;; PI-DECIMAL/BIG              414.84   415.35     0.00            0
;; PI-ATAN                       7.38     7.11     0.00            0
;; PI-RATIOS                    13.75    13.91     0.00            0
;; HASH-STRINGS                 11.31    11.05     0.00            0
;; HASH-INTEGERS                 4.51     4.34     0.00            0
;; SLURP-LINES                   0.01     0.02     0.00            0
;; BOEHM-GC                     10.92    10.64     0.00            0
;; DEFLATE-FILE                  1.27     1.31     0.00            0
;; 1D-ARRAYS                     0.07     0.08     0.00            0
;; 2D-ARRAYS                     4.92     4.91     0.00            0
;; 3D-ARRAYS                    10.62    10.34     0.00            0
;; BITVECTORS                    1.84     1.75     0.00            0
;; BENCH-STRINGS                 5.99     5.91     0.00            0
;; fill-strings/adjustable      43.07    42.73     0.00            0
;; STRING-CONCAT               121.96   119.59     0.00            0
;; SEARCH-SEQUENCE               5.07     5.18     0.00            0
;; CLOS/defclass                 1.00     0.64     0.00            0
;; CLOS/defmethod                0.29     0.34     0.00            0
;; CLOS/instantiate              6.38     6.47     0.00            0
;; CLOS/simple-instantiate      11.40    11.36     0.00            0
;; CLOS/methodcalls              6.22     5.99     0.00            0
;; CLOS/method+after             3.45     3.48     0.00            0
;; CLOS/complex-methods          1.54     1.43     0.00            0
;; EQL-SPECIALIZED-FIB           1.57     1.62     0.00            0

("Clozure Common Lisp Version 1.7-dev-r14645M-trunk  (WindowsX8632)"
("EQL-SPECIALIZED-FIB" 157/100 1623/1000 0 0) ("CLOS/complex-methods"
309/200 287/200 0 0) ("CLOS/method+after" 1723/500 3479/1000 0 0)
("CLOS/methodcalls" 6223/1000 5991/1000 0 0)
("CLOS/simple-instantiate" 2849/250 11357/1000 0 0)
("CLOS/instantiate" 6381/1000 6473/1000 0 0) ("CLOS/defmethod" 73/250
343/1000 0 0) ("CLOS/defclass" 997/1000 16/25 0 0) ("SEARCH-SEQUENCE"
1013/200 259/50 0 0) ("STRING-CONCAT" 121957/1000 119591/1000 0 0)
("fill-strings/adjustable" 43071/1000 5341/125 0 0) ("BENCH-STRINGS"
599/100 739/125 0 0) ("BITVECTORS" 461/250 1747/1000 0 0) ("3D-ARRAYS"
531/50 5171/500 0 0) ("2D-ARRAYS" 4923/1000 2457/500 0 0) ("1D-ARRAYS"
69/1000 39/500 0 0) ("DEFLATE-FILE" 637/500 131/100 0 0) ("BOEHM-GC"
5461/500 266/25 0 0) ("SLURP-LINES" 11/1000 2/125 0 0)
("HASH-INTEGERS" 4511/1000 542/125 0 0) ("HASH-STRINGS" 1131/100
2209/200 0 0) ("PI-RATIOS" 6873/500 2783/200 0 0) ("PI-ATAN" 7383/1000
7113/1000 0 0) ("PI-DECIMAL/BIG" 10371/25 415353/1000 0 0)
("PI-DECIMAL/SMALL" 53047/500 106361/1000 0 0) ("BIGNUM/PARI-200-5"
15804/125 15682/125 0 0) ("BIGNUM/PARI-100-10" 8121/1000 1012/125 0 0)
("BIGNUM/ELEM-10000-1" 917/50 17831/1000 0 0) ("BIGNUM/ELEM-1000-100"
2062/125 8081/500 0 0) ("BIGNUM/ELEM-100-1000" 451/200 2309/1000 0 0)
("CRC40" 5548/125 44147/1000 0 0) ("MRG32K3A" 7377/500 1471/100 0 0)
("MANDELBROT/DFLOAT" 173/500 39/100 0 0) ("MANDELBROT/COMPLEX" 361/500
86/125 0 0) ("ACKERMANN" 327/125 273/100 0 0) ("FIB-RATIO" 27/200 7/50
0 0) ("FIB" 313/1000 39/125 0 0) ("FACTORIAL" 359/250 71/50 0 0)
("RICHARDS" 4507/1000 2231/500 0 0) ("TRIANGLE" 2049/1000 503/250 0 0)
("TRAVERSE" 1923/1000 1747/1000 0 0) ("FPRINT/PRETTY" 7119/1000 297/40
0 0) ("FPRINT/UGLY" 2621/250 85/8 0 0) ("STAK" 8/5 433/250 0 0)
("TAKL" 157/100 63/40 0 0) ("TRTAK" 827/1000 827/1000 0 0) ("CTAK"
673/500 1497/1000 0 0) ("TAK" 41/50 873/1000 0 0) ("PUZZLE" 1923/1000
181/100 0 0) ("FRPOLY/FLOAT" 1983/1000 232/125 0 0) ("FRPOLY/BIGNUM"
121/100 593/500 0 0) ("FRPOLY/FIXNUM" 103/100 103/100 0 0) ("FFT"
291/1000 117/500 0 0) ("DIV2-TEST-2" 1577/1000 741/500 0 0)
("DIV2-TEST-1" 139/100 1231/1000 0 0) ("DESTRUCTIVE" 167/250 16/25 0
0) ("DERIV" 487/500 113/125 0 0) ("DDERIV" 449/500 119/125 0 0)
("BROWSE" 81/100 733/1000 0 0) ("BOYER" 2663/200 13089/1000 0 0)
("WALK-LIST/MESS" 9/125 47/1000 0 0) ("WALK-LIST/SEQ" 59/1000 31/500 0
0) ("SUM-PERMUTATIONS" 5707/1000 543/100 0 0) ("LOAD-FASL" 337/1000
7/25 0 0) ("COMPILER" 1523/500 2979/1000 0 0))



More information about the Openmcl-devel mailing list